Persuasion Games with Large Language Models

The idea of using technology to influence human decisions isn’t new—advertisers have been doing it for decades. But what if advanced AI could do it even more effectively? That’s the question Ganesh Prasath Ramani, Shirish Karande, Santhosh V, and Yash Bhatia explore in their paper, "Persuasion Games with Large Language Models."

🎯 The Goal

The primary goal of their research is to determine how effectively Large Language Models (LLMs) can shape user perspectives and influence decisions through persuasive dialogue. The researchers aim to leverage these models within a multi-agent framework to enhance persuasive communication in industries like insurance, banking, and retail.

🛠️ The Approach

Their approach is sophisticated, using a multi-agent framework where a group of agents collaborates to engage users in persuasive dialogues. Here's how it breaks down:

1. Simulated Personas: They created 25 distinct LLM-driven personas with various demographic, financial, educational, and personal attributes to simulate realistic user interactions.

2. Conversation Framework: A turn-based dialogue system is used, where the conversation agent makes final utterance decisions based on inputs from advisor and retrieval agents.

3. Resistance Analysis: User resistance is continuously analyzed, and both rule-based and LLM-based techniques are employed to counteract it.

4. Evaluation Metrics: Persuasion is measured through pre- and post-conversation surveys, user actions (like purchasing or visiting a site), and language analysis using predefined metrics.

🔍 What Makes It Unique?

Several aspects make this approach stand out:

• 🤝 Multi-Agent Collaboration: Multiple specialized agents work together to enhance the persuasive capabilities of the primary agent.

• 🔄 Dynamic Strategy Adaptation: The system analyzes and adjusts persuasion strategies in real-time based on user resistance and emotional state.

• 📊 Quantitative Measurement: A novel "Call for Action" driven measurement approach quantifies persuasion effectiveness through user decisions and survey responses.

🧪 The Experiments

The team conducted 300 conversations between 25 user agents and 3 sales agents across domains like insurance, banking, and investment. Each session included pre- and post-conversation surveys, a 20-dialogue limit conversation, and a purchase decision.

📈 The Results

The results were intriguing:

• 🕰️ Longer Conversations: Conversations were longer when users had neutral emotions compared to strong negative emotions.

• 👍 Positive Perspective Change: Higher in baseline scenarios (71%) compared to those with emotion modifiers (56%).

• 💰 Sales Success: Sales agents induced positive decisions in 35% of baseline cases and 28% with emotion modifiers.

• 🚫 Conversation Endings: Conversations often ended due to inadequate information from sales agents.

✅ Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• ✨ Enhanced Persuasive Capabilities: Through collaborative multi-agent systems.

• 🔄 Real-Time Adaptation: Adjusts to user resistance and emotional states.

• 📊 Quantitative Metrics: Provide clear insights into persuasion effectiveness.

Limitations:

• 📉 Inadequate Information: Conversations often terminated due to inadequate domain-specific knowledge integration.

• ⚙️ Marginal Differences: Persuasion language factors showed only slight differences across various emotional states, indicating room for improvement in dynamic strategy adaptation.

🏁 Conclusion

The study demonstrates that LLMs can effectively persuade and resist persuasion, creating significant perspective changes in users. However, there's a need for stronger domain context and more dynamic information retrieval to improve the overall efficacy of the persuasive agents. Future work will focus on enhancing agent memory and enabling more informed conversations through tool integration.

In essence, this research opens up new possibilities for using AI to influence human decisions. It’s not just about making a sale; it’s about understanding how people think and finding ways to engage them more effectively. And that’s a game-changer.

🚀 Explore the Paper: Interested in pushing the boundaries of what small language models can achieve? This paper is a must-read.

Subscribe for more insights like this!